Commercial
  • #commercialbynature
  • Support Request
  • Customer Login
  • Call: 01242 703400
  • Request a Callback
  • Order Catalogue
  • Search
  • Commercial
  • Office Supplies
  • Managed IT
  • Managed Print Services
  • Smart Technologies
  • Interiors
  • Print Management
  • Technology
  • Sustainability

How To Handle Smartphones In-Class: Ban or BYOD (Bring Your Own Device)

How To Handle Smartphones In-Class: Ban or BYOD (Bring Your Own Device)

Schools need to confront smartphones head-on. 86% or children aged 12-15 say that they regularly use a mobile phone, and 96% of children over the age of 16 own a smartphone. Many students regularly bring these devices to school. This can be a significant distraction. It also provides an opportunity.

Finding dedicated funds for IT purchases is a major challenge for schools. Investment in end-user devices, network infrastructure and educational software cannot always be made at the same time. 81% of surveyed education professionals thought that students had access to better devices at home than the schools could provide. 68% said that they already encourage students to use their own devices.

The in-classroom applications of smartphones are endless. Anything you could do with a tablet can be done on a smartphone. For example, in a physics class, students could use an app to collect acceleration data or measure sound intensity. In language classes, students can record themselves speaking and play it back to self-critique pronunciation.    

The Problem: Equality of Access and a Loss of Control

The most basic issue with BYOD policies is equality of access. Among 5-15-year-olds, only 46% said they owned a smartphone in 2017. Based on research by Ofcom, socio-economic factors do correlate with a decreased use of a wide range of devices. However, they do not correlate with tablet or smartphone ownership. But, fundamentally, not everyone has a smartphone.

What to do: There are two solutions to this issue. The first is to invest in a number of classroom devices that can be used by some students. The other is to only engage a BYOD strategy for group activities where you can make sure that those students with devices are evenly spread among the classroom. However, the inequity of BYOD is unavoidable.    

The second issue is control. When students are using their own devices, the ability to monitor and contain exactly what they do diminishes. This is a potential distraction and security problem.    

Smartphones: Integrate or Ban?

A 2015 study by the Centre for Economic Performance found that student performance improved by 6.41% of a standard deviation in schools that banned mobile phones. Looking at 91 schools in four English cities, the study concluded that low-achieving students benefited most from the ban — improving by 14.23% of a standard deviation. This would indicate that although BYOD policies are a workaround to budget constraints, the lack of control limits its utility.

This gets to the heart of the debate about smartphones and student-owned devices — ban them or engage with them. Although banning them seems like the easy thing to do there are exterior problems with this strategy, in addition to losing access to an already existing pool of technological teaching aids.

Many parents coordinate pick-ups and after-school activities through mobile phones. Phones are often purchased for children so that parents can contact them in an emergency. In 2015, the department of education for New York City lifted a highly unpopular ban of mobile phones for a host of reasons, including parental and student complaints.

Strategies for Controlling Personal Devices

  1. Establish Expectations: No matter what the approach, make sure to lay out clear ground rules about the use of mobile phones at the beginning of the year. This includes when and how they are allowed to be used and consequences for misuse. DON’T BE AFRAID TO TAKE THEM AWAY
  2. Consider Incentives: One of the main issues with controlling student behaviour is getting ‘buy-in’. Rather than penalising students for misbehaviour, provide incentives for conformity. For example, some classes base a percentage of their grade on participation points. Tying those points to not using mobile phones inappropriately, or even voluntarily surrendering phones at the beginning of class can be a good way to avoid distractions without generating resentment.
  3. Walk Around the Classroom: In order to know if students are on their phones, you need to be able to see them. If students think you will likely walk behind them with little warning, they are more likely to stay on task.
  4. Re-arrange the Desks: In addition to walking around, re-arranging the desks in your classroom into a semicircle will improve your ability to see what students are doing while depreciating their ability to reliably account for your position in the classroom.
  5. Give Your Students Tech Breaks: You can purposefully provide your students with a short phone break every 20 to 30 minutes. This can be attached to individual or collective cooperation with not using phones for unauthorised purposes.  
  6. Integrate Phones into Teaching: This comes back to BYOD policies — if students are using their phones for class exercises they may be less likely to use them for personal purposes.

Summary: Schools Need to Address Smartphones No Matter What, Integrating Them Into Lessons May Be a Creative Solution to That Problem

Smartphones have changed our lives and they are now disrupting education. Teachers are arguably best placed to assess the needs of their own classrooms and decide if smartphones are best harnessed for in-class activities, or banished as a distraction. It is possible, however, to do both at the same time and allow students to use their phones for only certain periods of the day.

In all cases, teachers must tread carefully. It is important to gain student buy-in when it comes to limiting smartphone use in-class. Integrating them into lessons comes with even more pitfalls. Teachers need to make sure that they don’t become a distraction and that their inequitable distribution does not disadvantage some students. The payoff, however, is access to an already existing pool of powerful technology that can empower digital learning strategies, both inside and outside the classroom.

“81% of surveyed education professionals thought that students had access to better devices at home than the schools could provide. However, bringing smartphones in to the classroom has it's pitfalls when it comes to which children have access to smartphones and the risk of reducing concentration." 

Richard Blundell

Divisional Director

  • If your office needs it, we can do it.
    Intelligently, efficiently, sustainably.

    Find out more
    Watch video

    • About us
    • Commercial by nature
    • Mission vision values
    • Our story
    • The complete office
    • Awards & accreditations
    • Contact & locations

    • Media & events
    • News & blogs
    • Events
    • Case studies
    • Video gallery
    • Downloads

    • Divisions
    • Sustainability
    • Office supplies
    • Technology
    • Interiors
    • Print management
    • Managed print services
    • Creative systems
    • IT services

    • Careers
    • Life at Commercial
    • How to Apply
    • Vacancies
    • Recruitment Agencies
  • Purpose for your business

    Find out more
    Watch video

    • Responsible sourcing
    • Procurement process
    • ETI membership
    • Products with purpose
    • Low-carbon deliveries
    • Circular economy
    • Modern slavery

    • Vision & Strategy
    • Dedicated sustainability team
    • 10 commitments
    • UN sustainable development goals
    • COP21 and science-based CO2 targets
    • Air quality impact
    • Resource consumption

    • Partnering & Added value
    • CSR day
    • Consultancy
    • ISO14001 & planet mark consultancy
    • Projects

    • Operations
    • On-site renewables
    • Renewable electricity
    • Zero waste to Landfill
    • Server cooling system

    • Professional recognition
    • Awards
    • Certifications
    • Memberships

    • Staff engagement
    • Change champions
    • Angel days
    • Charity charter

    • Commercial foundation
    • Buy social
  • Efficient office supplies with purpose in mind.

    Find out more

    • Why us
    • Your dedicated account team
    • Getting to know you
    • Implementation, reporting, progress reviews
    • Cost reduction

    • Product categories
    • Catalogues
    • Green Categorisation
    • Products With Purpose
    • Partnering Sustainably

    • Supporting you further
    • Free recycling
    • Confidential shredding
    • Social value reporting

    • Ordering & delivery
    • Online ordering
    • Punch out capability
    • White glove service
    • Just in time
    • Packaging & delivery
    • Low carbon deliveries
  • Make hardware buying easy, with a supplier that provides more than just product.

    Find out more

    • Why us
    • Expert advice
    • Direct OEM partnerships
    • Extensive product range
    • Bid price
    • Highly accredited

    • Services
    • Pre-configuration and support
    • Onsite technical support
    • End to end project management

    • Ordering & delivery
    • Online purchasing
    • Nationwide delivery
    • White glove delivery service
    • Waste removal
  • Bring your organisation to life 
with a unique interior.

    • Our Solution
    • Consultancy
    • Design
    • Move Management
    • Fit-Out
    • Furniture

    • Case Studies
    • View our latest case studies

    • About Us

    • Contact Us

    • News & Knowledge
  • High quality printing

    Find out more
    Watch video

    • Expertise
    • Strategic cost control
    • Dedicated team
    • Sector specific knowledge

    • Why us
    • Brand management
    • Print specialists
    • Single source procurement
    • Low-carbon deliveries

    • Our services
    • In-house production
    • Vendor management
    • Print Services
  • Partner with us for efficient printing, copying and scanning solutions

    Find out more

    • Why us
    • IT & business expertise
    • Continual improvement
    • Independent
    • Partners
    • Installation support
    • Consultation & analytics
    • Performance dashboards

    • Services & sectors
    • Professional Services
    • Outsourcing & MPS
    • Scanning
    • Sectors
    • Creative Industries
    • IT Services

    • After sales care
    • Account management
    • Training
    • Network Operation Centre
    • Field support
    • Customer relationship services

    • Support
    • Copier Toner Request
    • Copier Service Call
    • Copier Meter Readings
  • This is no longer science fiction. This is here. This is now….

    Find Out More

    • Why Us
    • Internet of things
    • Maximising revenue
    • World class CSR
    • Top 10 Reasons

    • Services
    • Digital Signage
    • Consulting
    • Custom Development
    • Monitoring and Support
    • Smart Vending

    • Sectors
    • Retail
    • Charities
    • Hyper Local
    • House Builders
    • Hospitality & Corporate
    • Out of Home Advertising

    • Contact Us

    • News & Views
  • Say goodbye to murky contract terms, and hello to service-led consultancy.

    Find Out More

    • Services
    • Book your print audit
    • Creative technology
    • Colour management
    • Creative workflow
    • Proofing
    • Office technology
    • Continual improvement

    • Products
    • Hardware
    • Software

    • About You
    • Print for creatives
    • Print for IT, production & office

    • About Us
    • Our story
    • Timeline
    • Meet the team
    • Sustainability

    • Contact us

    • News & views
  • IT with a Conscience

    Find out more Hardware Recycling
    IT with a conscience

    • Services
    • Network
    • Compute
    • Continuity
    • Apps
    • Security
    • IT Support
    • IT Assessment
    • Hardware Recycling

    • Sectors
    • Education
    • Legal
    • Enterprise

    • Why Managed IT
    • Ethical IT
    • Ground to Cloud
    • Vendors
    • Outcomes
    • 10 Reasons

    • Success Stories

    • News & Views
    • Commercial
      • Commercial
      • About us
        • Commercial by nature
        • Mission visions values
        • Our story
        • The complete office
        • Awards & accreditations
        • Contact & locations
      • Media & events
        • News & blog
        • Events
        • Case studies
        • Video gallery
        • Downloads
      • Divisions
        • Sustainability
        • Office supplies
        • Mananged IT
        • Technology
        • Managed Print Services
        • Creative Systems
        • Interior
        • Print Management
      • Careers
        • Visit our dedicated careers website
    • Office supplies
      • Office supplies
      • Why us
        • Your dedicated account team
        • Getting to know you
        • Implementation, reporting, progress reviews
        • Cost reduction
      • Product categories
        • Catalogues
        • Green Categorisation
        • Products With Purpose
        • Partnering Sustainably
      • Supporting you further
        • Free recycling
        • Confidential shredding
        • Social value reporting
      • Ordering & Delivery
        • Online ordering
        • Punch out capability
        • White glove service
        • Just in time
        • Packaging & delivery
        • Low carbon deliveries
    • Managed IT
    • Managed Print Services
      • Why Us
        • IT & business expertise
        • Continual improvement
        • Independent
        • Partners
        • Installation support
        • Consultation & analytics
        • Performance dashboards
      • Aftersales Care
        • Account management
        • Training
        • Network Operation Centre
        • Field support
        • Customer relationship services
      • Services & Sectors
        • Professional Services
        • Outsourcing & MPS
        • Scanning
        • Sectors
        • Creative Industries
        • IT Services
      • Support
        • Copier Toner Request
        • Copier Service Call
        • Copier Meter Readings
    • Smart Technologies
      • Why Smart Technologies
        • Internet of things
        • Maximising revenue
        • World class CSR
        • Top 10 Reasons
      • Services
        • Digital Signage
        • Consulting
        • Custom Development
        • Monitoring and Support
        • Smart Vending
      • Sectors
        • Retail
        • Charities
        • Hyper Local
        • House Builders
        • Hospitality & Corporate
        • Out of Home Advertising
      • Contact Us
      • News & views
    • Interior
      • Commercial Interiors Cheltenham and London UK
      • Workplace Consultancy from Commercial Interiors | The Commercial Group
      • Workplace Design, Commercial Interior Design | The Commercial Group
      • Workplace Fit-out by Commercial Interiors | The Commercial Group
      • Move Management by Commercial Interiors | The Commercial Group
      • Workplace Furniture Supplier by Commercial Interiors | The Commercial Group
      • About Commercial Interiors part of The Commercial Group
    • Print Management
      • Expertise
        • Strategic cost control
        • Dedicated team
        • Sector specific knowledge
      • Our Services
        • In-house production
        • Vendor management
        • Print Services
      • Why Us
        • Brand management
        • Print specialists
        • Single source procurement
        • Low-carbon deliveries
    • Technology
      • Technology
      • Why us
        • Expert advice
        • Direct OEM partnerships
        • Extensive product range
        • Bid price
        • Highly accredited
      • Ordering & Delivery
        • Online purchasing
        • Nationwide delivery
        • White glove delivery service
        • Waste removal
      • Services
        • Pre-configuration and support
        • Onsite technical support
        • End to end project management
    • Sustainability
      • Sustainability
      • Responsible Sourcing
        • Living wage
        • Procurement process
        • ETI membership
        • Products with purpose
        • Low-carbon deliveries
        • Circular economy
        • Modern slavery
      • Vision and Strategy
        • Dedicated sustainability team
        • 10 Commitments
        • UN sustainable development goals
        • COP21 and science-based CO2 targets
        • Air quality impact
        • Resource consumption
      • Partnering and Added Value
        • CSR day
        • Consultancy
        • ISO14001 & planet mark consultancy
        • Projects
      • Operations
        • On-site renewables
        • Renewable electricity
        • Zero waste to Landfill
        • Server cooling system
      • Professional Recognition
        • Awards
        • Certifications
        • Memberships
      • Staff Engagement
        • Green angels
        • Angel days
        • Charity charter
      • Commercial Foundation
        • Buy social
    Commercial

    If your office needs it, we can do it. Intelligently, efficiently, sustainably.

    • The Complete Office
    • Sustainability
    • Careers
    • Support
    Contact Us

    If you’d like to work with us or learn more about us, we’d love to hear from you.

    • 01242703400
    • hello@commercial.co.uk
    • 01242690006
    • officesupplies@commercial.co.uk
    • 08451133333
    • managedit@commercial.co.uk
    • 01242703400
    • mps@commercial.co.uk
    • 01242703400
    • interiors@commercial.co.uk
    • 02087587750
    • info@creativesystems.co.uk
    • 01242690006
    • print@commercial.co.uk
    • 01242703400
    • technology@commercial.co.uk
    • 01242703400
    • hello@commercial.co.uk
    • 01242703400
    • hello@commercial.co.uk
    Existing Customers

    Access your dedicated portal here. And we’re on the end of the phone if you need us.

    Customer login
    #commercialbynature
    • Privacy Policy
    • Cookies
    • Terms
    • Policy Documents
    • Modern Slavery Statement
    Back to top
    • © 2022 Commercial. All Rights Reserved.
    • Commercial Ltd. Head Office, Commercial House, Liddington Park, Old Station Drive, Leckhampton, Cheltenham, Gloucestershire, GL53 0DL UK. Registered in England No. 02589514
    • Commercial Ltd. Carrwood Park, Selby Road, Leeds, LS15 4LG UK
    • Wiles Greenworld Ltd. 1 Aintree Road, Perivale, Greenford, Middlesex, UB6 7LA UK. Registered in England No. 00380423
    Commercial

    If your office needs it, we can do it. Intelligently, efficiently, sustainably.

    • The Complete Office
    • Sustainability
    • Careers
    • Support
    Contact Us

    If you’d like to work with us or learn more about us, we’d love to hear from you.

    • 01242703400
    • hello@commercial.co.uk
    • 01242690006
    • officesupplies@commercial.co.uk
    • 08451133333
    • managedit@commercial.co.uk
    • 01242703400
    • mps@commercial.co.uk
    • 01242703400
    • interiors@commercial.co.uk
    • 02087587750
    • info@creativesystems.co.uk
    • 01242690006
    • print@commercial.co.uk
    • 01242703400
    • technology@commercial.co.uk
    • 01242703400
    • hello@commercial.co.uk
    #commercialbynature
    • Privacy Policy
    • Cookies
    • Terms
    • Policy Documents
    • Modern Slavery Statement
    Back to top
    • © 2022 Commercial. All Rights Reserved.
    • Commercial Ltd. Head Office, Commercial House, Liddington Park, Old Station Drive, Leckhampton, Cheltenham, Gloucestershire, GL53 0DL UK. Registered in England No. 02589514
    • Commercial Ltd. Carrwood Park, Selby Road, Leeds, LS15 4LG UK
    • Wiles Greenworld Ltd. 1 Aintree Road, Perivale, Greenford, Middlesex, UB6 7LA UK. Registered in England No. 00380423